In every arena—sports, academics, business, and even the military—competition has always been a force that shapes character and reveals people’s truest instincts. People admire it, fear it, and feel drawn to it because rivalry exposes something raw within human nature.
This is especially visible in a mystery story about a military rivalry, where honor, pride, identity, and discipline collide. Paul H. D’Anna captures this intensity vividly in The Commander In Chief’s Trophy: Second Edition, a novel that uses service academy pride as a lens to explore deeper truths about behavior, motivation, and the cost of winning.
At the center of this discussion is a simple but profound question: what does competition bring out in individuals and communities? Does it push people towards excellence, or does it expose darker impulses? The answer, as D’Anna’s story suggests, is not one or the other—but both.
The Dual Nature of Rivalry
Competition is a powerful motivator. When harnessed well, it fuels excellence, innovation, and progress. When mismanaged, it breeds resentment, aggression, and destructive decision-making.
In a 2015 study on the power of competition conducted by DiMenichi and Tricomi, participants in a competitive environment showed faster reaction times on a physical-effort task, indicating greater attention and effort under competition. The research also found that male participants react faster and put in more effort to the task.
Rivalries and competitions bring out the best in people. But sometimes it can drive people to engage in unhealthy behaviors and unethical practices to become winners. This duality helps explain why military rivalry can be both inspiring and dangerous.
In The Commander In Chief’s Trophy: Second Edition, D’Anna illustrates the razor-thin line between discipline-driven achievement and ego-driven escalation. When institutions place immense symbolic value on victory, the culture surrounding competition becomes amplified. People are competing not only for the trophy, but also for pride, belonging, and legacy.
Healthy Competition with Rivalry
When people look at different situations, they realize that competition can bring out some of the best aspects of human nature—discipline, courage, resilience, and teamwork. Understanding why helps clarify the positive psychological mechanisms at play.
1. It Strengthens Motivation and Personal Growth
A tough competitor or opponent makes people develop skills, discipline, attitude, and mindset. Generally speaking, good competition pushes people out of their comfort zones to be more persistent and creative—to be a better version of themselves. Growth rarely occurs in isolation or without effort; it occurs when people are pushed to do better than what they thought possible.
2. It Creates Community and Shared Identity
Paradoxically, competing against other teams for a prize or honor often builds unity within a team. Military academies exemplify this: cadets form lifelong bonds through shared struggle and pursuit of a common goal—trophy, recognition, or reputation. Their identity becomes more vivid and better understood through the competition.
3. It Encourages Ethical Responsibility and Discipline
Competition always needs to be balanced with integrity in structured environments. In military rivalry guided by strong and honest leaders, honor, duty, and accountability can be reiterated in the students. The desire to win becomes one framework for shaping a moral character.
These benefits reflect the positive aspects of competitive and friendly rivalry and behavior in the military setting, especially when institutions and individuals maintain a balanced, ethical perspective about things.
Image Source: Unsplash
How Competition Pushes Greatness
It’s time to explore the positive outcomes of competitions for groups or individuals. Here are the three points:
1. Competition Strengthens Discipline and Focus
Competitive environments help individuals set higher goals and keep them more focused on their jobs. At times, when challenged, people increase their productivity and processes to meet the expectation, sometimes exceeding it.
This effect is magnified in military settings. Cadets undergo intense physical and academic training. The rivalry motivates them to rise beyond comfort, complacency, and normalcy. D’Anna’s characters in the book embody this drive—using competition to sharpen their skills and push their limits.
2. Competition Builds Character and Integrity
Healthy rivalry teaches accountability. It makes people more aware and responsible with their decisions when they know their actions affect the outcomes of the team.
Military settings, with their core values identified in honor codes, drive home the point even further. In The Commander-in-Chief’s Trophy, a number of characters experience an ethical dilemma. Their external and internal decisions demonstrate that competition can involve a moral challenge as well as a physical or intellectual one.
3. Competition Inspires Innovation and Problem-Solving
Pressure sparks different levels of creativity. Teams and individuals often think faster to find solutions, strategize better, and adapt more effectively when they’re challenged.
In D’Anna’s book, rivalry pushes cadets to use cooperation, intelligence, and strategy to succeed — and sometimes to discover truths hidden beneath the surface of military life.
When Competitions Turn Toxic
It’s not difficult to recognize that competition can also bring out the darker corners of human nature. Reading D’Anna’s military mystery novel shows just how quickly ambition can take a turn to manipulation, deceit, and destructive decisions.
1. Pressure Can Lead to Unethical Behavior
People may choose deceitful ideas, unfair practices, or hurtful behaviors as the better route to take for the benefit of the entire group. In overly intense environments, performance-enhancing shortcuts, sabotage, and rule-bending become temptations that are difficult to resist. Choices such as these break down trust, fairness, and relationships. Often, toxic competition begins with small compromises and secrets that snowball downhill into moral ruin.
2. Rivalry Can Create Division and Conflict
When winning is everything to a group, for instance, opponents are no longer viewed as respected competitors but rather threats that get in the way of achieving goals. These circumstances create hostility, resentment, and tensions among competitors and within oneself. In real-world military contexts, fractured cohesion can compromise mission readiness and morale, breaking or making a team in the process.
3. It Elevates Stress and Lowers Well-Being
Excessive competitiveness contributes to burnout, anxiety, and impaired judgment in people. People in highly competitive and high-pressure environments will develop chronic stress and other internal issues. When applied to military contexts, such stress can be dangerous for the person themselves and the people around them.
These consequences and potential issues demonstrate the benefits and downsides of competition, highlighting why leadership and ethics matter profoundly within any rivalry-driven environment—like military academies. Additionally, competition outcomes can influence participants’ responses to the situations.
Explore the Power of Competition
So, what does competition bring out—our best or our worst? The answer depends largely on the environment, leadership, and personal values guiding the competitor. Competition is not inherently good or bad; it is a catalyst. It amplifies what already exists within us—discipline or ego, ambition or insecurity, integrity or opportunism.
Paul H. D’Anna’s The Commander In Chief’s Trophy: Second Edition captures this truth brilliantly. Through the lens of military rivalry, he reveals how competition becomes a crucible for character, shaping identity in lasting ways. Grab a copy of this novel today!
